The Napoleon Tin Button Theory
Imagine this: the fate of one of history’s greatest military campaigns could have been determined by something as small as the
buttons on a soldier’s uniform!
This fascinating idea is known as the Napoleon Tin Button Theory. It suggests that during Napoleon’s
ill-fated Russian campaign, a hidden flaw in the material of his soldiers’ uniform buttons may have contributed to their downfall.
At the time, the French military used tin (Sn) buttons, not knowing that tin can exist in different forms, or allotropes,
which behave very differently in cold weather. Tin has two primary allotropes: alpha-tin and beta-tin. Alpha-tin is a dull,
brittle material with little practical use, while beta-tin is shiny, malleable, and perfect for making buttons.
However, there was a catch—beta-tin can transform into alpha-tin when exposed to temperatures below 13°C.
This process, known as “tin pest,” can cause the buttons to crumble into dust.
As Napoleon’s troops marched into the freezing Russian winter, where temperatures plummeted to as low as -40°C, the tin buttons
might have begun to disintegrate. Without buttons to keep their coats closed, the soldiers were left vulnerable to the harsh cold.
While many factors, such as disease, starvation, and harsh conditions, played a role in the retreat of Napoleon's army,
this intriguing theory suggests that something as simple as faulty buttons could have added to their misery.
Doesn’t that make you wonder about the small details that can change the course of history?
Reality of Urban legends, it remains true that the beta-to-alpha phase transition in tin is absolutely spectacular, as you can see
in the following video where a sample of beta tin is exposed to low temperatures.
(Please note that commercials are authomatically inserted by youtube).
Back to teaching page
